Young v. Keyes — Plain Language Summary

Citation: No. 24-2763, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit (decided May 19, 2026)

Facts

On New Year’s Eve night in Williston, North Dakota, a police officer pulled over Ronald Young after observing him make an illegal turn. The officer noticed signs of alcohol intoxication and conducted field-sobriety tests. During the encounter, Young became argumentative and declined to say whether he would agree to an additional alcohol screening. Justia

At that point, according to Young’s complaint, the officers grabbed him without warning, ordered him to put his hands behind his back, and — with the help of a second officer — took him to the ground and handcuffed him. Young claims he suffered physical injuries and emotional harm as a result. Justia

What Young Argued (the Lawsuit)

Young sued both officers under federal civil rights law, alleging they used excessive force in violation of his Fourth Amendment rights. Justia

What the District Court Decided

The trial-level district court granted the officers’ motion to dismiss, ruling that the force used was minimal (de minimis) and, alternatively, that it was objectively reasonable. The district court relied on dash-camera and body-camera footage, finding those videos consistent with the complaint’s account. Justia

The Legal Issue on Appeal

Did Young’s complaint allege enough facts to survive dismissal — specifically, did the video footage definitively disprove his claims of excessive force, or did factual questions remain that required further proceedings?

What the 8th Circuit Held (Reversed in Young’s Favor)

The Eighth Circuit reviewed the dismissal de novo (a fresh, independent review) and found that the video evidence did not conclusively contradict Young’s allegations about the severity of the force used or the absence of any resistance on his part. Justia

The court also reaffirmed a key legal principle: under clearly established law, force is least justified against nonviolent misdemeanants who do not actively resist arrest or pose a threat. Justia

Conclusion

Because Young’s complaint alleged facts that, if taken as true, would constitute a violation of his clearly established constitutional rights — and because the video did not refute those allegations — the Eighth Circuit reversed the district court’s dismissal and sent the case back for further proceedings. Justia

Bottom line in plain English

A man stopped for a minor traffic violation on New Year’s Eve claimed police suddenly grabbed him, took him to the ground, and handcuffed him without any warning or justification, causing him injuries. The lower court threw out his lawsuit, saying the force was minor or reasonable. The 8th Circuit disagreed, ruling that the dashcam/bodycam footage didn’t clearly disprove his version of events, and that the law is well-established that police can’t use force against someone who isn’t resisting or posing a threat. Young gets to continue pursuing his case because the video evidence presented was not clearly supportive enough in favor of the officers to dismiss the case.